In June 2020, the Monterey Herald reported that the board of the Monterey Peninsula Water Management District first formally opposed the desalination project of California American Water (Cal Am). By four votes to three, it backed a letter urging the Coastal Commission to refuse the permit. The district saw a 2,250 acre-foot expansion of the Pure Water Monterey recycling project as a replacement. Cal Am spokeswoman Catherine Stedman called desalination the only way to meet the Carmel River orders. The commission was due to consider it in August.
The report showed how desalination and water recycling competed as alternative paths on the Monterey Peninsula and how the dispute was tied to plans to take over the private water utility.

